How do I reach out to old contacts without being awkward?

Direct Answer

Reaching out to old contacts is less awkward than it feels: most assume you're too busy for them and are glad to be invited back in. Lead with warmth and their world, never a pitch. I teach a formula for this, and my response rates run 30 to 40% against the 1% a typical sales email gets.

Leah Neaderthal

Leah Neaderthal

Founder, Smart Gets Paid

Best Move

Send a short, warm note that leads with them and offers an outcome, with zero pitch attached.

Why It Works

Old contacts already trust you, and research finds reconnected ties deliver fresher insight than current ones.

Next Step

List ten people who know your work and haven't heard from you in a year. Write to two.

What you need to know

Nobody wants to hire a consultant. They only want the outcomes in their business.

Leah Neaderthal, Smart Gets Paid

Why does reconnecting feel so awkward when it isn't?

Reconnecting feels awkward because you're imagining how the note looks from a version of them that doesn't exist: someone tracking your silence, suspicious of your motives. The real person on the other end is busy, thinks well of you, and has assumed you're too busy for them.

Your clients and past clients know how good you are, which is exactly why they talk themselves out of reaching for you: she's probably booked, she probably doesn't even do this work anymore. Your note doesn't interrupt them. It gives them permission.

The research backs the feeling being wrong. Levin, Walter, and Murnighan studied executives reconnecting with contacts they hadn't spoken to in three or more years, and found dormant ties proved as valuable as current ones, and often more valuable: "Insights from dormant ties tend to be more novel, and more efficient to get, than those from current ties." Two things made it work, and you already have both:

  • The trust never left. Years of dormancy don't erase the credibility you earned. People were generally pleased to hear from old contacts.
  • The silence created value. They've been in different rooms since you talked, and so have you. You're each other's freshest source.

What do I say when I reach out after years of silence?

Say something short and warm that leads with them, and follow a structure so you're never staring at a blank message. The one I teach, the Shoulder Tap Formula, builds the note from five parts:

  1. Relevance: the reason it's them, today. "I was thinking back to our conversation about the rebrand."
  2. Warmth: an actual human opening. "Happy new year. I hope the move went well."
  3. Something new: what you've been building or learning since you talked, in one line.
  4. The outcome for them: what it might change in their business or their team's quarter. Lead with that, never with your services.
  5. One easy ask: "Is that something you'd want to hear more about? I have 20 minutes Thursday or Friday."

That's the shape that gets my 30 to 40% response rate. Notice what's missing: any pitch, any apology for the silence, any paragraph about you. It's the same posture as posting without sounding salesy: give first, ask small. The whole note reads like a colleague sticking her head in the door, and that's precisely why it works.

Who should I reconnect with first?

Reconnect first with the warm people just below the surface: past clients, former colleagues, and the people who already know your work. I call this digging the potatoes, because they grow six inches down, right within reach, and no farm expansion required.

Past clients who loved the work

They're one good reason away from hiring you again, and they're the people referrals already flow through. Add one extra ingredient for them: remind them what you offer and that you have room. They assume you're booked solid, and a plain "I'm taking on one more project this fall" turns that assumption into an opening.

Former colleagues who've moved

Every job change relocates someone who trusts you into a new company with new problems and new budget. The trust travels with them.

The near-misses

People you almost worked with, where the timing was wrong and the respect was real. Timing changes.

Reaching out to strangers has its own etiquette, and it comes second, whether you do it yourself or pay an agency to do it for you. This list first. The potatoes are closer than you think.

Leah's take

Look, I know what the hesitation is made of. Reaching out feels like asking for something, and you were raised to never impose. So let me flip the frame: done right, reconnection is offering something. You show up warm, you lead with their world, you put an outcome on the table, and you make the next step cost twenty minutes. Nobody experiences that as an imposition. Most people experience it as the most useful email they got that week.

And this is not chasing. Chasing is pursuing someone who's gone cold on a live deal. This is a peer saying hello with something to offer, from the same level, with no grip on the outcome. If they're not interested, nothing was lost, and you're back on their radar anyway.

The women I work with put off this exact activity for months, and then one afternoon of notes produces more real conversations than a quarter of posting. The warm lane was sitting right there the whole time.

The Academy is where I teach the full formula, with a room of women doing the same work.

More questions about this topic

Is it too late if it's been five years?

No, and the gap might be the asset. The reconnection research found long-dormant ties deliver the freshest insight precisely because you've each been in different rooms since you talked. Trust doesn't expire on a schedule, and neither does respect for your work. Write the note as if the gap is normal, because to them, it is.

Should I apologize for being out of touch?

No. Nobody was keeping score, and an apology turns a warm hello into an awkward accounting. Open with warmth and relevance instead: the memory of them, the reason it's today. "It's been too long" as a passing beat is fine. A paragraph of guilt makes them manage your feelings, which is the opposite of a gift.

What if an old contact never replies to my note?

Some will, and the note still did its job: you're back on their radar, warmly, with no strings. One friendly nudge a couple of weeks later is plenty, and then let it rest. This works as a steady practice across many people, never as a campaign aimed at one. The next note to someone else matters more than the silence from this one.

Can I reconnect just to ask for referrals?

Don't lead there. A note that exists to extract a referral reads as a pitch no matter how it opens, and people feel the difference immediately. Reconnect to reconnect: warmth, their world, something useful. Once the relationship is warm again, the people who love your work refer naturally, and the ones who ask "how can I help?" have just answered your question for you.

Related pages

Leah Neaderthal

Leah Neaderthal

Leah Neaderthal is the founder of Smart Gets Paid, where she has helped hundreds of women consultants attract more of the clients they want and get paid more for their work. For more than a decade, she has taught women consultants how to bring in clients on purpose and get paid more for their value, through her program, The Academy. She's also the host of The Smart Gets Paid podcast. Learn more at smartgetspaid.com.

www.smartgetspaid.com
Mary G, nonprofit consultant
I just secured a contract for 500% more than I was originally going to quote. I was ready to undervalue my bid and ask for $7,000 but I reached out to Leah and the team for a pep talk and I'm glad I did, because we are now going under contract for $37,500!! I'm stoked!
Denise F, marketing consultant
I was my reviewing my revenue dashboard and it showed that I earned $100K more in 2024 compared to the year before. I joined the Academy in May 2024 and it has transformed my sales approach entirely.
Sarah J, fundraising consultant
We used to book clients just in time to keep income flowing, and we now have a 6-month cushion!

Get more of the clients you want, and get paid more for your work

Leah writes to women running B2B consulting businesses every week, about getting clients on purpose and getting paid for the value of the work.

Sign up for the newsletter Apply to The Academy