Should I hire a sales coach or figure it out myself?

Direct Answer

Hire the coach if what you're missing is judgment, and do it yourself if what you're missing is only information. Most women running consulting businesses have plenty of information. What they don't have is someone who has done this telling them which option fits their business. You can get there alone. The question is what that route costs in years.

Leah Neaderthal

Leah Neaderthal

Founder, Smart Gets Paid

Best Move

Decide which one you're short on, [information or judgment](/guides/ai-vs-sales-coach/), and buy only the one you're missing.

Why It Works

Information is everywhere and nearly free. Judgment about your specific business is the part that stays expensive.

Next Step

Write down the last three business development decisions you postponed, and notice whether you lacked facts or confidence.

What you need to know

The satisfaction of self-reliance is real, and it is expensive.

Leah Neaderthal, Smart Gets Paid

What does a sales coach actually do for a consulting business?

A sales coach for a consulting business does three things a course can't, and none of them is handing you information.

She tells you which option is right for you

There are usually ten reasonable ways to handle a stalled opportunity, and nine of them are wrong for your business, your client, and this particular moment. Choosing between them is judgment.

She works your live deals with you

The real engagement sitting in front of you, with the person who's gone quiet, the budget cycle you didn't know about, and the internal politics nobody wrote down.

She notices

When you say you'll send five follow-ups and send one, somebody knows. When you drop your price before anyone pushed back, somebody names it. That's the part you can't buy in a document.

I get coached too. There's a bonus episode where I'm the one in the chair ("Bonus Episode: Leah gets coached"), and I put it out on purpose, because the idea that you graduate out of needing help is one I'd like to retire.

Can I learn to get clients from free content?

You can learn a great deal about getting clients from free content, and I'd rather you did than sat still. My podcast is free. This page is free.

Here's where free content stops. It hands you pieces, from a dozen people who each believe something slightly different. Then you assemble them yourself, and what you get is parts that don't quite line up: gears whose teeth don't mesh. You can't tell which piece is the problem.

You have some of the ingredients. You're just missing the recipe.

And that's structural. MIT and Harvard studied six years of their own free online courses, 565 of them, and found completion rates stayed low the whole time, with most learners never coming back after the first year ("The MOOC Pivot," Science, 2019).

The other thing free content can't do is tell you it isn't working. It has no idea what you tried, what you dropped, or what you're avoiding. It answers the question you thought to ask, which is a real limitation when you don't yet know what you don't know.

Get more out of the free material you're already reading:

  • Pick one source and go deep for a quarter instead of sampling ten. Conflicting advice is what produces the mismatched pieces.
  • Write down the one thing you'll try after each episode, with a date. Reaching out to people who already know your work is a good first one.
  • Keep a running list of what didn't work. That list is the most valuable thing you'll bring to a coach later.

How long does it take to figure out sales on my own?

Figuring out sales on your own takes longer than the time you'd spend learning it, because most of it isn't learning. It's trying something, waiting three to eighteen months to find out whether it worked, then not being sure whether the result came from the thing you changed or something else.

That feedback loop is the problem. A B2B consulting sale is slow by nature, so a mistake takes a year to show up and looks like bad luck when it does.

Working it out aloneWorking with someone who's done it
How you find out something's wrongThe deal doesn't happen, months laterSomeone tells you on the call
How many cycles you getA handful in a decadeTheirs, not just yours
What a mistake costsA year, and you may misread the causeA conversation
What you carry meanwhileThe self-doubt about whether you're doing it rightSomebody else's certainty until yours arrives

The honest version: you'll be fine either way. Plenty of women have built good businesses the slow way. What I'd want you to weigh is that what you're spending is a year of wondering whether you were doing it right.

Why do I feel like I should be able to figure out sales myself?

You feel that way because figuring things out yourself is who you have always been, and it has worked every single time until now.

You were the person who figured things out. In your corporate career you were either left to work it out alone or praised for it, probably both, and self-reliance stopped being a strategy and became part of your identity. So asking for help feels like evidence about you.

That's the trap, and I want to name it plainly. Nobody taught you to sell. It wasn't on the syllabus, it wasn't in your job, and there was no reason it should have been. You're meeting the first thing your usual method doesn't crack.

Smart women hire help for things outside their expertise constantly, without a flicker of shame. This is the same category.

Two things that help more than deciding to feel differently:

  1. Write down what figuring it out alone has cost so far. Months, opportunities you didn't pursue, the price you didn't ask for. Put real numbers on it.
  2. Name one thing you already outsource without shame (your accountant, your lawyer, your web developer) and say out loud what makes this different. Usually the honest answer is nothing.

How do I know if I'm ready to work with a sales coach?

You're ready to work with a sales coach when you have a real business and a specific problem, not when you feel qualified.

Concretely, the floor I hold:

  • Two or more years running your consulting business.
  • $120,000 or more in revenue last year.
  • Clients who are happy with your work. Results are not the question, and what the help costs is a separate one.

That floor exists because coaching multiplies something. If the underlying work isn't strong yet, there's nothing to multiply.

The other signal is behavioral, and it's the one I'd weigh most: if you're postponing decisions you have every fact you need to make, the gap is confidence. That's what coaching is for.

If you're earlier than that, don't hire anyone yet. Go get the reps, and keep the list of what didn't work.

Leah's take

Real talk: I'm not going to tell you that you can't do this yourself. You probably can. You've done harder things, and plenty of women have.

Here's what I'd ask you to look at instead. Figuring it out yourself feels good. There's a real satisfaction in having scraped it together, and I did it that way myself. But at what cost? How long did it take? And how much self-doubt did you carry the whole way about whether you were even doing it right? That second cost is the one nobody counts.

Your time is the one thing you can't get more of. So when someone says she'd rather work it out alone to save money, what I hear is that she's about to spend the more expensive currency to protect the cheaper one. The women I work with say it almost the same way every time: I'll be fine, I just won't get to where I want to go as fast as I want to get there.

You're allowed to take the shortcut. That's the part I most want you to hear.

The Academy is where I teach both systems, with a room of women doing the same work.

More questions about this topic

Isn't hiring a coach admitting I can't do it myself?

No, and it's the objection that comes up most. Hiring a coach is a statement about speed. You hire an accountant without concluding you're bad at math. Sales is the one place smart women attach their competence to doing it unaided, and that belief costs more than the help does.

What's the difference between a sales coach and a business coach?

A business coach works across your whole business: operations, team, pricing, direction. A sales coach works on how clients come in and how they say yes. For a consulting business those overlap, so ask whether the person has done what you're trying to do, with your kind of client.

Can I learn on my own and work with a coach at the same time?

Yes, and that's what most people should do. Keep reading and listening; that part is free and it builds your instincts, and [a course can be the right buy for a specific skill](/profitable-consulting-business/getting-help-ai-coaches-courses-communities/node-3.html). Bring in help for the decisions where being wrong costs you a year.

How do I know coaching will work for my kind of consulting?

Ask whoever you're considering how the approach changes for your kind of engagement, and listen for whether the answer is specific. Business development for a B2B consulting business runs on the same spine across marketing, brand, org development and the rest: several decision-makers, a long cycle, and a real process.

Related pages

Leah Neaderthal

Leah Neaderthal

Leah Neaderthal is the founder of Smart Gets Paid, where she has helped hundreds of women consultants attract more of the clients they want and get paid more for their work. For more than a decade, she has taught women consultants how to bring in clients on purpose and get paid more for their value, through her program, The Academy. She's also the host of The Smart Gets Paid podcast. Learn more at smartgetspaid.com.

www.smartgetspaid.com
Mary G, nonprofit consultant
I just secured a contract for 500% more than I was originally going to quote. I was ready to undervalue my bid and ask for $7,000 but I reached out to Leah and the team for a pep talk and I'm glad I did, because we are now going under contract for $37,500!! I'm stoked!
Denise F, marketing consultant
I was my reviewing my revenue dashboard and it showed that I earned $100K more in 2024 compared to the year before. I joined the Academy in May 2024 and it has transformed my sales approach entirely.
Sarah J, fundraising consultant
We used to book clients just in time to keep income flowing, and we now have a 6-month cushion!

Get more of the clients you want, and get paid more for your work

Leah writes to women running B2B consulting businesses every week, about getting clients on purpose and getting paid for the value of the work.

Sign up for the newsletter Apply to The Academy